Sourcing
Why Two Suppliers Quote Differently for What Looks Like the Same Sheet
Published
Two quotes for a "white 300 thread count percale queen sheet set" usually differ because the sheets are not the same product. The gaps sit in what the line on the quote does not say: cloth weight, yarn and ply, finish, construction details, packing, and the commercial terms around the price. Before you read a quote as expensive or cheap, rebuild both onto one written specification and compare again.
The quote is a summary, the cloth is the detail
A one-line product description feels precise to a buyer and is loose to a mill. "Cotton percale, 300 thread count, queen" fits a light, crisp cloth and a heavier, denser one. It fits a sheet with a full elastic perimeter and one with elastic only at the corners. A supplier filling the gaps will fill them differently, and each choice moves the cost.
So the first question is not "who is cheaper" but "what did each supplier assume". If the quotes came from a brief that was one line long, the difference you see is mostly the difference in assumptions.
Where the same-looking sheet actually differs
Fibre and yarn
Cotton is not one input. Staple length, the grade of the lint and whether the yarn is carded or combed change the feel, the strength and the cost of the cloth. Two suppliers can both write "100% cotton" and be using different raw material.
The same holds for linen, where the yarn can be made from long line flax or from shorter tow fibre, and the lea count changes how fine the cloth is. The label on the quote rarely says which.
Cloth weight and construction
Weight per square metre is the most useful single number on a specification, because it tells you how much yarn is in the cloth. Two sheets with the same nominal thread count can differ in weight if the yarn counts differ. A heavier cloth uses more yarn and more weaving time, and costs more to make.
Thread count has its own trap. A count built by plying fine yarns can be inflated without making the cloth better. If a quote gives a thread count without saying whether it is single ply or two ply, ask. The ply belongs next to the number.
Finish
Finishing is where a lot of invisible cost lives. A sheet that goes through a softening or pre-washing process arrives soft and mostly shrunk. A sheet that skips it arrives crisper and will shrink in the buyer's first wash. Both can be legitimate, but they are not the same item, and the second will usually quote lower.
Dye and colour
White, dyed, yarn dyed and garment dyed are four different routes with four different cost profiles. A deep colour generally costs more than a pale one, and colour matching to a reference adds steps that a supplier working to "close enough" will skip. Ask whether the quote includes a lab dip against your reference and whether the colour is matched to a Pantone TCX number or to the supplier's nearest shade.
Making details
These are small on paper and add up across thousands of sets:
| Detail | What can vary between quotes |
|---|---|
| Fitted sheet pocket depth | A shallow pocket uses less cloth than one made for a deep mattress |
| Elastic | Full perimeter, corners only, or a lighter elastic |
| Flat sheet hem | Width of the top hem, and stitch density |
| Pillowcase closure | Envelope with an overlap, or a sewn-in opening with no overlap |
| Seams | One flat seam or a double-turned finish; one cloth width or pieced |
| Stitch quality | Stitches per inch, thread type and finishing of loose ends |
Cloth width matters as well. A loom that weaves wide cloth lets a large flat sheet or duvet cover be cut without a centre seam, while a narrower loom needs a join. Neither is wrong, but a seam changes the look and the cost.
Packing
A sheet set folded into a polybag and a sheet set in a rigid retail box with an insert are very different packing jobs. Cartons, labels, barcodes, hang tags and inner packs should each be on the quote as a line, or at least stated as included.
The commercial terms matter as much as the cloth
Even when the sheet is identical, two quotes can be on different footing.
- Incoterm. A price on FOB and a price on CIF are not comparable until you bring them to the same basis. The first leaves freight and insurance to you, the second includes them to the destination port.
- Minimum order and how it is split. A low price may rely on a high minimum per size or per colour. A price at a lower minimum, split across several sizes, is a different offer.
- Sample treatment. Some suppliers charge for samples and credit them against the first bulk order. Others give them free and carry the cost in the unit price.
- Lead time. A shorter production time often means the supplier has fabric in stock, which may be a standard cloth rather than yours.
- Tolerance. Quantity, size and weight tolerances are rarely on a quote, and a looser tolerance lowers the price while giving you less certainty.
Why the lowest quote sometimes wins fairly
It is worth conceding that a lower quote is not always a trap. A supplier with a stronger position on yarn, or one that runs a simple construction at volume, can legitimately be cheaper for an identical product. A cloth made on equipment that suits that exact construction costs less than the same cloth forced onto the wrong machine. A fair comparison has to leave room for that.
The test is whether the cheaper quote still meets your written specification. If it does, the price is the price. If you cannot tell, you have found the gap in your brief, not in the supplier.
How to compare quotes properly
- Write one specification: fibre, ply and count, cloth weight, finish, colour reference, construction details and packing.
- Send the same document to every supplier and ask them to quote against it, noting any change they would make.
- Ask each supplier to state the Incoterm, the minimum order per size and colour, and whether samples are charged.
- Request a counter sample from the top two or three and check it against your specification: weigh it, measure it, wash it.
- Compare landed cost, not ex-works price, once you have the freight and duty position for your market.
Counter samples are where most disagreements are resolved. At H & J Exim, counter samples on woven take about one week and on knitted about 10 days from an agreed specification, and they are chargeable and adjusted against the first bulk order. Whoever you use, the sample is cheaper than learning the difference in a container.
If you want to see how a specification flows into terms, the private label page sets out minimums, sampling and lead times, and the woven range shows the constructions we make. When you are ready to brief a supplier, get in touch.
Common questions
Is the cheapest quote usually a lower quality sheet?
Not always, but it is a reason to check. A lower price can come from a lighter cloth, a skipped finish, a looser tolerance or a different basis such as ex-works. Match the specification first, then judge the price.
What is the single most useful number to put in a bed linen specification?
Cloth weight in grams per square metre, together with the ply and count. Weight shows how much yarn is in the cloth, and the ply stops a thread count from being inflated.
Should I ask every supplier for a sample before comparing?
Compare written quotes first to remove obvious mismatches, then request samples from the two or three that remain. A sample you can weigh, measure and wash tells you more than any description.
Do quotes on different Incoterms compare directly?
No. An FOB price excludes sea freight and insurance, and a CIF price includes them to the named port. Convert both to the same basis before comparing, and add inland costs at your end.